Sudell Team - Serving Avalon and Stone Harbor New Jersey

8808 First Avenue, Stone Harbor

For Sale: $5,495,000   |   Under Contract

MLS: 189913   |   Bedrooms: 8   |   Bathrooms: 4   |   Type: Single Family   |   Lot: 6001-10000 SqFt   |   DOM: 308 Days

8808 First Avenue, Stone Harbor

For Sale: $5,495,000 / MLS: 189913

Beds: 8 /
Baths: 4 /
Single Family

Lot: 6001-10000 SqFt /
DOM: 308 Days
Content loaded.

This extraordinary oceanfront property is a one of a kind combination of a premium location, an oversized, 9,250 square foot lot, a 4-story structure that is still able to be expanded approximately 1,200 square feet, all while housing one of Stone Harbor's most memorable homes. Known as the Oceanview Lodge, this very special home was first constructed in 1910, and extensively renovated over the past 15 years by Craig Otton. The charm is immediately overwhelming upon entering the property from the sidewalk, as the fenced-in yard features lush, mature landscaping and a beautiful front stair, leading to large deck that flanks the entranceway. The front door actually enters on the second floor, which is the primary interior entertaining space. The custom kitchen features extravagant millwork, Subzero and Wolf appliances, an expansive center island with a mahogany countertop. An oceanview from the kitchen sink is the cherry on top. The living room is centered on a gas fireplace and also offers an extensive millwork package including coffered ceilings, a built-in mantle with bookshelves on both sides, and storage for games and television components. The ocean side dining area has seating for the entire family and offers slider access to the massive second floor deck, with both a covered and uncovered entertaining spaces. The third and fourth stories are dedicated to bedrooms and bathrooms, with the entire fourth story serving as the master-suite. This beautiful 4th story space features an extraordinary trim package, a spacious, oceanfront master bathroom, a separate office (a space that could easily function as another bedroom), and some of the best views available in all of Stone Harbor. The fourth story is one of, if not the highest residential single family space in all of Stone Harbor and is a grandfathered use. All three ocean front decks offer some level of relief from the sun, whether it's a fixed awning on the second floor, a covered deck on the third floor, or retractable awnings on the fourth, or master level. The first level is an in-law suite, with two large bedrooms, a recently renovated full bathroom, a large living area and a full kitchen. This great space walks out back to one of, if not the best rear yard entertaining space in all of the 7 Mile Island. An enormous pool is accented with a waterfall and fountains shooting out of the surrounding, blue stone pavers. Walk back a couple more steps to find a newer outdoor kitchen, complete with a fire pit and an outdoor TV. A few steps further leads you to a gazebo and a seating area centered on a stone waterfall that is built-in to the elevated landscaping. This rear yard space is truly an entertaining oasis that is unmatched on the island. Perhaps most interesting of all, this sprawling, four story home can be expanded. While this property has a deed restriction that limits the building footprint to the oceanmost side of the neighboring oceanfront (to the north), there is approximately 22 feet of lot depth that is undeveloped (33 feet back to the structure, excluding decks). Since Stone Harbor does not regulate floor to area ratio, this space can be added on to the existing structure, potentially creating an additional 1,200 square feet of living space. On top of that addition, you could create a roof top deck atop the second story of the addition that could become the single best entertaining space on the island. The post addition structure could be 4,500 - 5,000 interior square feet, which under any other circumstance would require a 10,000 plus square foot lot which is not easy to come by! This truly extraordinary property is one of Stone Harbor's most historic homes, one of the towns most memorable homes, and, now, one its most desirable properties currently listed for sale. Schedule your appointment today.


  • Dishwasher   
  • Disposal   
  • Dryer   
  • Microwave Oven   
  • Range   
  • Refrigerator   
  • Self-Clean Oven   
  • Smoke/Fire Detector   
  • Stove Electric   
  • Stove Natural Gas   
  • Washer   
  • Cable TV   
  • Deck   
  • Enclosed/Covered Patio   
  • Fenced Yard   
  • Grill   
  • In Ground Pool   
  • Outside Shower   
  • Patio   
  • Porch   
  • See Remarks   
  • Sidewalks   
  • Sprinkler System   
  • Whirpool/Spa   
  • Den/TV Room   
  • Dining Area   
  • Eat-In-Kitchen   
  • Great Room   
  • Kitchen   
  • Laundry/Utility Room   
  • Living Room   
  • Recreation/Family   
  • See Remarks   
  • Heating:Forced Air   
  • Heating:Gas Natural   
  • Heating:Multi-Zoned   
  • Heater:Gas- Natural  
  • Fireplace- Gas  
  • Wood Flooring  
  • Kitchen Center Island  
  • Walk in Closet  
  • Cooling:Ceiling Fan  
  • Cooling:Central Air Condition  
  • Cooling:Multi Zoned  
  • City  
  • See Remarks  
  • Victorian  

Last Database Update: 07/29/2021 05:15:23

Let The Sudell Team be your buyer agent for this listing. Listing is provided by FERGUSON-DECHERT, INC. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web page appears in part through the Cape May County MLS program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which we participate, and is provided by Cape May County MLS through a licensing agreement. Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to change, withdrawal, or prior sale.
8808 First Avenue, Stone Harbor

For Sale: $5,495,000 / MLS: 189913

Beds: 8 /
Baths: 4 /
Single Family

Lot: 6001-10000 SqFt /
DOM: 308 Days
Content loaded.
What Our Clients Have To Say About Our Teams Dedication To Service
Test Read More >
The Sudell Team with Ferguson Dechert Real Estate Ferguson Dechert Real Estate
Get Social   Facebook   Instagram   Twitter   YouTube   LinkedIn Location Direct Phone Office Phone
- Meet The Team
- Client Testimonials
- Newsletters / Sign Up
- Office Directions
- Exclusive Properties
- Ferguson Dechert Listings
- Search The MLS
- Avalon Properties
- Stone Harbor Properties
- What’s My Property Worth
- Search Rentals
- Let Us Help
- List Your Rental
- Owners
- Plan Your Vacation
- 7 Mile Island Market News
- Local Weather Forecast